India was one of the first few countries to ratify the United Nations Convention of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. In 2016, the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act was enacted. But this wasn’t enough to ensure that digital accessibility was being implemented in India.
It has taken two case laws, that have made the Government of India, Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment and the Department of Persons with Disabilities finally start to look at the implementation of accessibility in India.
Rajive Raturi vs Union of India
What is the background of the case?
Rajive Raturi, a visually impaired individual had filed a Public Interest Litigation PIL in Hon Supreme Court of India way back in 2005. The litigation asked for providing meaningful access to public spaces for persons with disabilities. In the decision given on 15 December 2017 the court had provided eleven action points in its judgement. The court had directed the Central and State Government to take measures to make its buildings, transport facilities and information and communication technologies accessible for people with disabilities.
What task was assigned to Centre for disability studies CDS- NALSAR University of Law by the court?
In the order dated 29-11-2023, the court was dissatisfied with the progress made by the central and state governments in implementing its direction. Therefore the court directed CDS- NALSAR to submit a report on the steps required to make all State and Central Government buildings, airports, railway stations, public transport carriers, all Government websites, all public documents and the ICT ecosystem fully accessible to persons with disabilities within a period of 6 months.
What were findings of CDS- NALSAR?
The report pointed out that inaccessibility of public spaces increases the discrimination for people with disabilities. It was observed that courts, prisons, education and employment opportunities were not accessible for people with disabilities. Emotional and relational challenges were highly faced by people with disabilities. People with disabilities found it difficult to access various health facilities. They also found it difficult to participate in sports activities. The report also observed that there is inconsistencies in the existing Legal Framework. It opined that rule 15 on accessibility of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities RPWD rules is inconsistent with the provisions of the RPWD Act on accessibility.
What are the views on accessibility expressed by the court in this judgement?
In the judgement delivered on 8 November, 2024, the court stated that “Accessibility refers to the design of products, services, environments, and systems to ensure that all individuals, including those with disabilities, can access, use, and benefit from them fully and independently”. It is important that the court has explained the term accessibility in best possible manner. The court once again stated that Right to accessibility is an integral part of the various fundamental rights provided in the Indian Constitution. The court has provided a two-fold approach. It stated that existing infrastructure be made accessible through retrofitting on one hand. On the other hand, new infrastructure must be made accessible from the initial stage itself.
What is the main issue discussed in the judgement of 2024?
The court has analysed rule 15 (1) of the RPWD rules in light of provisions on accessibility in the RPWD Act. It is pointed out that the mentioned rule is in contravention with the provisions of the Act. The court pointed out that standard for public buildings, standard for Bus Body Code, Culture sector specific harmonised accessibility standards and so on notified by various ministries are mere guidelines and they are not rules, which are non-negotiable. They also do not prescribe any consequences in case they are not complied with by any organization.
What were the directions given in the judgement?
The court directed Central government to formulate mandatory rules on accessibility in accordance with section 40 of the RPWD Act within 3 months. Once the mandatory rules are framed the Central and State governments are required to work in accordance with section 44, 45, 46 and 89 of the RPWD Act. The court directed to consider the principles of universal design, Comprehensive Inclusion Across Disabilities and Assistive Technology Integration. The court admired the work done by CDS- NALSAR and directed the ministry of social justice and empowerment to pay Rs.50,00,000 for the work done by them.
Must Read RPwD Act, 2016: What Organizations Must Know About Accessibility Compliance
Pragya Prasun vs Union of India with Amar Jain vs Union of India
The Hon Supreme court heard and disposed of two cases together as common issues were found by the court.
What were the facts in the case?
Pragya Prasun is an acid attack victim, who suffered from facial disfigurement and severe eye burns. Amar Jain is a person with blindness .
On account of their disability, they found it difficult to complete the digital KYC / e-KYC process. They were unable to click a live photograph. As a result, they were unable to open a bank account and purchase a SIM card from the telecom providers.
What were directions asked in the case?
The various regulatory bodies were directed to formulate appropriate rules and guidelines for conducting Digital KYC/ e-KYC / Video KYC process through alternative methods. It was requested that the process be made more inclusive and accessible for people with disabilities. It was also prayed that adequate measures be undertaken to guarantee accessibility and provide reasonable accommodations for persons with disabilities, in accessing financial services, telecommunications, and government schemes.
What were the court’s observations?
The court observed that there is an increase of accessing various essential services, governance, education, healthcare and so on through digital platforms. It is necessary that digital content be made accessible so everyone can access the content effectively. The court felt it important to interpret Digital Accessibility in light of Article 21 of the Constitution. The court expanded the meaning of Article 21 of the constitution and held that right to digital access is an intrinsic component of the right to life and liberty. It therefore necessitates that the State proactively design and implement inclusive digital ecosystems.
What were the directions given by the court?
It can be clearly understood from this judgement that the court clearly respected the rights of people with disabilities. It is clear that the court truly believed in inclusion of people with disabilities. With a view to make the digital KYC / e-KYC process accessible the court set out various directions. The directions mainly emphasized that all regulatory authorities should provide alternative modes and options for completing the KYC procedure. The court also directed the appropriate regulatory authorities to amend their regulations to facilitate alternative means for completing the KYC. Few important directions in this ruling were.
- All organizations to follow accessibility standards.
- Appointment of nodal officer in every department for digital accessibility compliance
- To undertake accessibility audits of websites, mobile apps
- To establish a dedicated grievance redressal mechanism for persons with disabilities by all regulating authorities.
India is finally moving towards ensuring accessibility is mandatory. It isn’t optional. Today public and private entities need to build inclusion and accessibility that will include people with disabilities not exclude them. BarrierBreak can be your trusted partner in this journey, helping you move from intent to impact by embedding accessibility into every digital experience. Get in touch with us today and let’s build an Inclusive Digital India together.
Subscribe to ACE Learning courses and explore how disability laws evolved into a global human rights movement, empowering you to drive inclusion and change worldwide.
